What does the public want on immigration?

Submitted by lucidity on Wed, 04/12/2006 - 10:10am.

Pollster Ruy Teixeira at Donkey Rising examines U.S. attitudes toward immigration. Read the whole post for the details, but these are his six main findings:

  1. The public believes immigration is a serious problem and levels of concern appear to be growing.
  2. The public generally believes that immigrants don't displace American citizens from jobs.
  3. On the other hand, the public does believe immigration depresses wages.
  4. The public overwhelmingly wants tougher action to keep illegal immigrants out of the country.
  5. But there is little enthusiasm for an enforcement approach that focuses exclusively on illegal immigrants themselves and removing them from the country, especially when posed against alternatives.
  6. The public is open to a guest worker program for illegal immigrants and to making it easier for them to obtain citizenship, but only if certain strict conditions are met.

With regard to #5, "49 percent said the best way to reduce illegal immigration from Mexico was to penalize employers, compared to 33 percent who chose increasing border patrols and 9 percent who favored building more fences." This is the common-sense solution — reduce the demand for cheap, illegal labor and you reduce the supply of illegal labor.

Unthinkable musings

#140 On Thu, 04/13/2006 3:50am Larry Bergan said,

I'm really glad the poll shows that most people get it on question 5! The power people always manage to get the downtrodden fighting each other. The minuemen yelling at the immigrants at the city and county building were livid at Bush. If we could just get the two groups together!

Sensenbrenners bill wants to make people who were lured into the country into felons and you have Dana Rorenbaucher (spelling?) saying we should use prisoners to pick fruit for free! Are these two plans connected to increase profits for the ones hiring illegals now! Even the conservative commentator David Brooks, who can be seen on PBS's News Hour smells a rat here. He said (in so many words) this looks like slavery. Bridge to the 21st century?

NPR, paraphrased

#141 On Thu, 04/13/2006 8:10pm emoticon said,

I was listening to NPR on the divisive methods being used to keep the african american community and undocumented immigrants separate-jobs and anger, the root of all evil

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.