Are Americans living beyond their means?

Submitted by lucidity on Wed, 10/15/2008 - 11:34am.

Former Secretary of Labor Robert Reich (TAPPED):

The "living beyond our means" argument, with its thinly veiled suggestion of moral turpitude, is technically correct. Over the last fifteen years, average household debt has soared to record levels, and the typical American family has taken on more of debt than it can safely manage. That became crystal clear when the housing bubble burst and home prices fell, eliminating easy home equity loans and refinancings.

But this story leaves out one very important fact. Since the year 2000, median family income has been dropping, adjusted for inflation. One of the main reasons the typical family has taken on more debt has been to maintain its living standards in the face of these declining real incomes.

It's not as if the typical family suddenly went on a spending binge — buying yachts and fancy cars and taking ocean cruises. No, the typical family just tried to keep going as it had before. But with real incomes dropping, and the costs of necessities like gas, heating oil, food, health insurance, and even college tuitions all soaring, the only way to keep going as before was to borrow more. You might see this as a moral failure, but I think it's more accurate to view it as an ongoing struggle to stay afloat when the boat's sinking.

What if you can't borrow more?

#823 On Thu, 10/16/2008 3:51pm miriam said,

When you've reached your cash, resource and credit limits, where else is there to go for help? Not much out there!

And then try to figure out who cares...after all, it's not the government's responsibility to help, and we certainly shouldn't be "spreading the wealth". (McCain 10/15/08)

I've been hearing arguments that "he who doesn't work shouldn't eat". Let's see what happens to those who believer this when they lose their jobs, benefits and savings. Maybe then, they'll be quoting the parts about "feeding the poor".

Keep on hoping!
Miriam

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.