Unlike liberals, conservatives will accept a partial victory now
There's been a lot of debate going on at AMERICAblog over whether transsexuals should be included in the Employee Non-Discrimination Act (ENDA) along with gays and lesbians (the votes are there to pass an LGB bill, but not an LGBT bill). And while that subject itself is somewhat off-topic for this blog, John Aravosis at AMERICAblog has some interesting things to say about how liberals and conservatives approach the challenge of getting difficult legislation passed (Salon.com):
Conservatives understand that cultural change is a long, gradual process of small but cumulatively deadly victories. Liberals want it all now. And that's why, in the culture wars, conservatives often win and we often lose. While conservatives spend years, if not decades, trying to convince Americans that certain judges are "activists," that gays "recruit" children, and that Democrats never saw an abortion they didn't like, we often come up with last-minute ideas and expect everyone to vote for them simply because we're right. Conservatives are happy with piecemeal victory, liberals with noble failure. We rarely make the necessary investment in convincing people that we're right because we consider it offensive to have to explain an obvious truth. [...]
Civil rights legislation — hell, all legislation — is a series of compromises. You rarely get everything you want, nor do you get it all at once. Blacks, for example, won the right to vote in 1870. Women didn't get that same right until 1920. The Civil Rights Act of 1964 provided a large umbrella of rights based on race, religion, sex and national origin, but failed to mention gays or people with disabilities. People with disabilities were finally given specific rights under the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990, but gays as a class have still to be granted a single civil right at the federal level. If we waited until society was ready to accept each and every member of the civil rights community before passing any civil rights legislation, we'd have no civil rights laws at all. Someone is always left behind, at least temporarily. It stinks, but it's the way it's always worked, and it's the way you win.





Recent comments
3 hours 35 min ago
1 day 2 hours ago
3 days 2 min ago
3 days 4 min ago
3 days 5 min ago