archives

Vouchers: An idea whose time has gone

Submitted by lucidity on Fri, 05/02/2008 - 10:28am.

Greg Anrig says conservatives have essentially abandoned their pursuit of private-school vouchers. Good article overall, but an inaccurate account of what happened in Utah last year:

In 2000, both California and Michigan offered referendums on voucher programs for all children in the state. The initiatives were defeated by margins of forty-two and thirty-eight points, respectively. Voucher supporters like to blame the defeats on well-funded teachers unions, but the law professors James E. Ryan and Michael Heise found that voucher supporters had outspent the opposition in Michigan, and both sides had spent about the same amount of money in California. They concluded that the decisive resistance to vouchers had come from suburban voters who feared that the programs would take money away from local schools and worried about the arrival of lower-income and minority students in their children's classrooms. And last year, in the conservative, predominantly white state of Utah, the Republican legislature put a November referendum for a voucher program on the state ballot, which Overstock.com CEO Patrick Byrne and his family supported with about $4 million. It lost by 62 percent to 38 percent — the eighth decisive loss for a statewide voucher ballot initiative. There have not been any victories.

Your summer reading list of anti-conservative books

Submitted by lucidity on Fri, 05/02/2008 - 10:34am.

Back in 2006, I remarked "it's about time liberals start taking aim at conservatism itself" and not just individual conservatives like George Bush, Bill O'Reilly, and Ann Coulter. It looks like others had similar thoughts, because there's a bumper crop of anti-conservative books available now.